Lenders charge more: the shaded band
Borrow more, pay more. It's true for households, and economists have measured it for the US government too.
What the band is
On the front-page chart, each path's line is its market rate exactly as named: Hold stays flat, Fall sits at 3.5%, Level off stops at 7%. The shaded band above the highlighted line — topped by a dotted line labeled "+ lenders charge more" — is the extra lenders demand because the debt keeps growing. The top of the band is what new borrowing actually costs on that path, and it is the rate the countdown uses.
The rule
For every percentage point of debt above 100% of GDP, new borrowing costs 3 basis points (0.03 points) more. At 150% of GDP that adds 1.5 points; at 200%, 3 points. The effect starts at 100% because that is roughly where the debt stands today, and today's market rates already price today's debt. It applies to every path except Official, which follows CBO's published rate path as is.
Where 3 basis points comes from
It sits in the middle of a well-established research range:
- CBO's own economists (Gamber and Seliski, 2019) estimate about 2 to 3 basis points per point of debt.
- Thomas Laubach of the Federal Reserve, whose 2009 study is the standard reference, found roughly 3 to 4.
- The Dallas Fed (Plante, Richter and Zubairy, 2025) finds about 3, and notes CBO uses 2 in its projections.
- Federal Reserve Board economists (2026) find 3 to 4 basis points on real 10-year yields, most of it through the term premium.
Why it stops at 250% of GDP
Every one of those studies was estimated on debt levels far below 250% of GDP; Japan, around that level, is the highest any rich country has carried. Beyond it the relationship has never been measured, so the clock doesn't extrapolate it: the extra charge stops growing at 4.5 points. That is a conservative choice — nothing suggests lenders would charge less at 300% than at 250%.
Why Official doesn't have it
CBO's long-term projections hold the average interest rate near 4.2% even as debt heads toward 175% of GDP. Researchers at Brookings have called that implausible, and the clock's Official path shows where it leads: a crossing that only arrives in the 2140s because rates never respond to a debt several times the size of the economy.
Sources
- CBO Working Paper 2019-01: Gamber & Seliski, The Effect of Government Debt on Interest Rates
- Dallas Fed: each point of debt raises long-term rates about 3 basis points (2025)
- Federal Reserve Board FEDS 2026-031: The Causal Effect of Debt on Interest Rates
- Brookings: The federal debt path is worse than reported